The Original Josie's Pizza

Ashley Wooten 5 months ago

Usually we stick to the same thing have been ordering for years!! But today I switched up and got the chicken sub and was highly impressed it was cooked well crispy and fresh and the fried mushrooms are really good! My grandma stuck with her usual and got the BLT pizza and good as always love this place will continue ordering as long as it’s around!!

Paul Sheffield 6 months ago

Josie's is one of the oldest pizza joints in Columbus. Opened in 1959 and still family owned. We met the third and four generation owners while there. The pizza was basically the perfect Columbus tavern style. The crust was thin and had a great crunch from the edge to the center. The sauce was homemade and delicious. The pepperoni was excellent and the ingredients were fresh. It was cooked perfectly. This is what Columbus style is all about. There was a very welcoming vibe and I would highly recommend Josie's to everyone!

John Michael Adelman 10 months ago

Zero complaints, Austin was very welcoming and open to sharing about the Sicilian roots of his family. I brought my Sicilian wife (Italians somehow always manage to find other Italians while they're out and about, kind of like magnets or something🧲🇮🇹😄) and our niece Josie with us for her birthday and it was honestly one of the highlights of my year. They've got historical family documents detailing their voyage over to New York from Sicily which manages to give the place an authentic, homey and endearing feel and they've got plenty of room for large groups and a game room which was unexpected. Their chicken tenders are surprisingly flavorful and delicious and although I don't typically like bar or tavern style pizza theirs was solid. Pro tip that the great grandson of the woman the restaurant's named in honor of shared with me; you can ask for the pizza(s) you order to be cut in standard, triangular pie pieces which slightly alters the taste of the pie so I'll try that next time I go😋🍕

Arthur Jameson a year ago

The chef special is epic. Regular pepperoni under the cheese, smaller pepperoni on top. WOW. Thin crusted with LOTS of cheese and meat. Left me feeling full with FOOD and not bread. This family run business is a friendly, delicious place to come for great food and a good time. Prices were super good, too! Highly recommend.

Brooke Lindsay Edited a year ago

Great pizza served up by lovely family and staff in a spacious location that is great for dining and can support parties and events. Pool table, fun games, large bar and plenty of space to stretch out. Family run restaurant for over 50 years! Fast and friendly delivery or dine in. Perfect way to support a local business and eat some delicious food too!